Skip to main content

Creating Smiles

for a Life Time

Family and Cosmetic Dentistry with Dr. Dagmar Colon

- Evansville, Indiana

With over 25 years of experience, Dr. Dagmar E. Colon offers a combination of skill and gentle compassion that result in worry-free, comprehensive dental care for you and your entire family. “Hi! I’m Dr. Colon, and I wanted to thank you for stopping by our website. I understand that each patient’s needs are unique, and my staff and I pledge to listen to you,  and to fully understand your dental needs and concerns. Whether it is routine check-up and hygiene needs, general restorative work, or comprehensive cosmetic  procedures, we can help you get the smile you want.”

Smiles on 1st, Evansville, IN - Dr Dagmar Colons

Congratulations to Dr. Dagmar E. Colon, DDS for winning the 2015 Patients’ Choice Awards in Evansville Dentistry

Verified by

What Our Patients are Saying…

Dr Colon is a 5 star plus! Dr Colon and her staff are very friendly and very professional. Going to the dentist can sometimes cause nervousness, not here. The atmosphere is very relaxing and offices are very clean and lobby is professionally decorated. You know exactly how long you will be there and they take you at your appointment time. I have been going to Dr Colon for four years and every visit is as nice as the first. I highly recommend her.


Wonderful experience! From so friendly receptionist to state of the art equipment, and professional staff at all levels. Excellent teeth cleaning job by hygienist, and working me into schedule for follow up treatment. Highly recommend Dr.Colon and her staff.

Jayne Buthod

Just moved to the area and and super excited to find this awesome dentist! Hygienist KIm was very thorough and knowledgeable. Dr Colon was gentle and caring. The whole staff was super friendly, was a great over all experience. Definitely my new dentist!!

Andrea Gibbs

Normally, I don't write reviews for places I go to but I'll can easily say this is a phenomenal place. Great staff, great building, and Kim did an amazing job at not only explaining to me what she was doing but why she was doing. She did great to make me feel comfortable when I was nervous. Really like this place👍👍👍

Cody Parker

Dr. Colon and her staff are the best. I was having a toothache and they were able to get me in that day! Dr. Colon was very gentle and assessed my problem. She was very concerned about my pain level during my exam. I wouldn't want to go anywhere else! Highly recommend Dr. Dagmar Colon.

Kimberly Schapker

Dr.Colon and her staff are very client oriented with the utmost professionalism and care for their patients. I am very satisfied with their service and would highly recommend them for any of your dental needs.

Cindi Klueh

We've been seeing Dr Colon for years professional and friendly I like the reminding messages since we have 4 boys easy to keep up and flexible they work with you staff is great and office is super clean usually they on time Thank you

Hannah Abed

I've had bad experiences with being shamed by dentists before so I hadn't been to one since 2015. The staff here are very kind and respectful, the rooms are very nice, and the hygienist are patient, kind, and very informative of what they're doing!

Ashley Lester

The staff here is absolutely amazing. They are very thorough and explain anything at all that they're doing and why. It is a breath of fresh air to have people that are so caring and understanding.

Tammy Hodge

Everyone in the office is amazing. I highly recommend Dr. Colon and her staff. I couldn’t be more pleased.

Heather Rogers

Always know when I go I will be taken care of from start to finish. I feel like I’m with my friends. Angie I want you to know how lucky I was to have found the best hygienist ever. I will miss you!!!! Everyone I am grateful for all you do. Dr. Colon and entire staff are the best.

Patty Gill

The staff is very nice and friendly and extremely knowledgeable and I love the hygienist Angie she is very kind and very thorough with the cleanings. Dr. Colon is kind and very caring and keeps me up on the care of my teeth.

Yolanda Bard

We got in on time, everyone was very nice. Everything was explained to us and to my son who of course was a bit nervous. I got a good feeling about this being a very professional office and am glad that I found it for my son.


Very nice and do a great job makes me feel comfortable 😊 works with my work schedule to get the right appointment time that works for me yayyyyyyyyy thank you going to miss Angie though but i hear someone that i know is coming back 😊 i hope so

Dennis Daily

The staff is always friendly and very professional. Dr. Dagmar is very reliable and cares about every single detail including the type of brush you use.


Staff is awesome ! And They always do their best ! U need a new dentistry this one is great !

Christine M Goebel

I love their work and care that they do for my daughter ❤️ What a wonderful staff they have.

Nina Fletcher

My new crown feels like it belongs. I am very satisfied, as I always am with Dr. Colon!

Maureen Stephenson

Exceptional staff. Very welcoming and personable across the board. Dr. Colon and her team are extremely professional. Great first visit.

Stacie Wallace

Dr. Colon and staff are very professional and knowledgeable in their jobs! They are caring and know how to make their patients feel comfortable. The staff always recommend new things to help keep my teeth healthy. Love you Dr. Colon and company!

Gilda Cartagena

My three children and myself LOVE Dr. Dagmar Colon and her staff. It is always a great experience. Very clean, beautiful/family oriented place. Lovely ladies that took care of my children and their teeth 🙂 such a friendly staff and very knowledgeable. Very happy with the experience.

Ashley Ratcliff

I have not been to the dentist in 2 years. It's always the same reason, money. I had a bad tooth ache a week ago , called to make my appointment and was a little nervous. They took a complete set of x-rays to see what was going on. The young lady that cleaned my teeth was very thorough and new how and what she was doing. It wasn't as bad as I thought. I have been going to Doctor Dagmar for years and her staff is very concerned about their patients and doing a careful and caring job to see that their teeth are well taken care of. Thank you Doctor Dagmar for your help in my dental care.

Margaret Edinburgh

Staff is awesome and very patient with kiddos too, love them. Dr. Colon is the best!!!


I absolutely love this place. Everyone there is extremely nice and welcoming. My whole family goes here and I'm so glad I found them.

Jessica Shane

Friendly staff. Very nice facility. I’ve been to a few different dentist in my days but this Lady is very thorough and easy to talk with. Had teeth cleaned today and the Hygienist was very friendly and did one of if not the best job Ive ever had. Highly recommend this facility. You will not be disappointed. Hi Aleasha

Jeff Jennings


Dagmar Colon D.D.S Smiles on 1st Dental services

We provide dental services ranging from the most basic dentistry, to Cosmetic rehabilitation. Dr. Colon and her highly-trained staff offer a full range of dental services, whether it is general needs, reconstructive, along with wide range of cosmetic services, and much more. Below is a list of many of the services we provide.

General Dentistry
  • Cleanings & Exams
  • Periodontal/ Gum Therapy
  • Restortive Work (fillings)
  • Crown & Bridge
  • Simple Extractions
  • Comprehensive Treatment Planning
  • Emergency Treatment Planning
  • Nitrous Oxide Sedation (laughing gas)
Cosmetic Dentistry
  • Teeth Whitening
  • Veneers
  • Implants
  • Partial Dentures
  • Implant Supported Complete Dentures


Crowns or ‘caps’, cover the entire tooth when the tooth is compromised with a large filling. When a tooth has a large filling breaks or chips, usually the portion of the tooth that is broken is the tooth, not the ‘filling’.  Crowns are also placed on teeth that have had root canal treatment because of a probable fracture.


Bridges are used to replace a missing tooth or teeth by placing crowns on both sides of a space where a tooth was extracted.  The space is filled in with a ‘bridge tooth’, and it is connected to the two crowns.


This is the removal on non-restorable teeth.


Permanently ‘whiten’, and in some cases, ‘straighten’ your teeth using veneers. Veneers fix spaces and chips with minimal tooth reduction, if any. Veneers mask intrinsic stains, and can also lengthen short teeth. No shots!

Clear Aligners

Clear aligners, also called invisible aligners, fix misaligned teeth and bites. They are a virtually invisible and removable alternative to braces designed around convenience and flexibility.

The aligner trays are made of BPA-free plastic and are custom-made for every patient.Each tray discreetly moves the teeth in small increments.

Aligner trays are routinely swapped out every 2 to 3 weeks until the teeth are straight and aligned. How many trays you need depends on the severity of teeth misalignment (also called malocclusion).

Some aligners do not touch your gums at all. They are trimmed to comfortably sit along your gum line in a ‘scalloped fashion.’ This design makes the trays less irritating and even more ‘invisible.’

Implant Restorations

Dental Implants are placed in the jaw to replace missing teeth. Once healed, the implants are fitted with implant crowns to restore proper form and function of the teeth that were missing.

Comprehensive Treatment Planning

We create a treatment plan for the entire mouth. We inform our patients of the ‘needed treatment’ (cavities, etc) and give plans for restoring the entire dentition, estimating insurance coverage when needed.

Dr Dagmar Colon DDS - Smiles on 1st Dental
Meet the Dentist

Dagmar Colon D.D.S

Dr. Dagmar E. Colon received her Doctorate of Dental Surgery from Indiana University School of Dentistry in 1993. She accepted a position in Evansville, Indiana. Dr. Colon established several dental offices in the Evansville and Newburgh, Indiana area. Where she made a home for her and her family for 25 years. Dr.Colon has attended extensive hours of  dental continuing education on a variety of subjects. She enjoys all aspects of family dentistry and cosmetic dentistry. During her free time she enjoys reading a good book and spending time with her family.

Dr. Colon has been  a member of the American Dental Association, the Indiana Dental Association, the First District Dental Society and  the American Academy of General Dentists .She has been a part of several study groups that relate to topics in Implant dentistry, orthodontics, cosmetic dentistry and pediatrics.

Smiles on 1st
3012 N.1st Ave, Evansville, IN 47710
Call Now | Text or Chat Now

    Dr. Colon and her staff welcomes patients with disabilities. If you need an accommodation to receive dental services, or to make an appointment, or to discuss your financial obligation we would be happy to provide you with any assistance needed  Please contact us at 812-423-0113  to let us know how we may be of assistance.


    Tel  812.423.0113
    Text 812.423.0113
    Fax  812.423.4857
    Chat Now

    photo credit: freepik

    Smiles on 1st

    3012 N.1st Ave,
    Evansville, IN 47710


    Mon   8 AM – 5 PM
    Tues   8 AM – 5 PM
    Wed   8 AM – 5 PM
    Thur  7:30 AM – 3PM

    Smiles on 1st
    Dagmar E. Colon D.D.S